International Journal of Law And Criminology
35
https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc
VOLUME
Vol.05 Issue06 2025
PAGE NO.
35-39
10.37547/ijlc/Volume05Issue06-08
International Copyright Regulation: Legal Gaps and
Future Prospects in Virtual Space
Lapasov Asliddin Tolqin og’li
Head of the Department of the Center for Professional Training of Legal Personnel according to International Standards at Tashkent State
Law University, Uzbekistan
Received:
23 April 2025;
Accepted:
19 May 2025;
Published:
21 June 2025
Abstract:
The rapid evolution of digital technologies and the increasing globalization of online content distribution
have highlighted significant challenges in international copyright regulation. While treaties such as the Berne
Convention and the WIPO Copyright Treaty provide a foundation for global copyright protection, inconsistencies
in national legal frameworks create enforcement difficulties in the virtual space. This article explores key legal
gaps, including jurisdictional conflicts, differing interpretations of copyright exceptions, and the challenges of
cross-border enforcement. Additionally, it examines future prospects for harmonizing copyright laws through
digital innovations such as blockchain, artificial intelligence enforcement, and international cooperation. By
addressing these legal disparities and leveraging technological advancements, a more effective and unified
approach to copyright regulation in the digital age can be achieved.
Keywords:
International copyright regulation, legal gaps, virtual space, digital copyright protection, cross-border
enforcement, Berne convention, WIPO copyright treaty, copyright harmonization, jurisdictional conflicts, fair use
exceptions, digital piracy, blockchain for copyright.
Introduction:
The evolution of digital technology has
reshaped the global copyright landscape, highlighting
legal gaps in international copyright regulation. While
treaties such as the Berne Convention and the WIPO
Copyright Treaty provide a foundation for protection,
inconsistencies in national implementations create
enforcement challenges in virtual space. This article
explores key legal gaps, jurisdictional conflicts, digital
piracy issues, and the difficulties of applying traditional
copyright laws to emerging technologies. Additionally,
it examines potential future solutions, including
international harmonization, blockchain technology,
artificial intelligence for copyright enforcement, and
enhanced cross-border cooperation. Addressing these
challenges is essential to create a more equitable and
effective global copyright system in the digital era. As
digital content becomes more accessible and shareable
across borders, copyright protection in virtual space
faces significant legal challenges. While international
agreements aim to provide a standardized framework,
variations in enforcement and national policies hinder
effective copyright protection . This article examines
the gaps in international copyright regulation, focusing
on legal inconsistencies, enforcement challenges, and
the future prospects of copyright governance in digital
spaces.
Copyright laws vary significantly across different
jurisdictions, creating substantial challenges for
enforcement in the digital space. While international
agreements such as the Berne Convention for the
Protection of Literary and Artistic Works and the WIPO
Copyright Treaty (WCT) establish general principles for
copyright protection, their implementation differs
from country to country. This lack of harmonization
makes it difficult to regulate copyright infringement,
particularly in the context of digital content, which is
easily distributed across borders . The lack of
harmonization in copyright laws remains a major
challenge in the digital age. While international treaties
provide a foundation for copyright protection,
inconsistencies in enforcement, fair use doctrines, and
ISP liabilities create legal uncertainty . Moving toward
stronger international cooperation, standardized
digital copyright policies, and effective enforcement
International Journal of Law And Criminology
36
https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc
International Journal of Law And Criminology (ISSN: 2771-2214)
mechanisms is essential for ensuring that copyright law
remains relevant in the evolving digital landscape.
Copyright enforcement is inherently territorial, yet
digital platforms operate globally. This creates conflicts
where a copyright-infringing website may be hosted in
a country with weak enforcement mechanisms while
targeting users in stricter jurisdictions . The absence of
a unified international legal framework makes it
challenging to regulate copyright violations effectively
in virtual space. Jurisdictional conflicts in virtual space
arise due to the borderless nature of the internet,
which allows digital content, services, and transactions
to cross multiple legal systems simultaneously.
Traditional legal frameworks are based on territorial
sovereignty, meaning that laws are typically enforced
within the geographic boundaries of a state. However,
when copyright infringement, cybercrimes, data
privacy violations, or digital trade disputes occur
online, determining which jurisdiction's laws apply
becomes a significant challenge. Jurisdictional conflicts
in virtual space remain a major challenge due to
differences in national laws, cross-border copyright
infringement, ISP liabilities, and privacy regulations.
While international treaties, cross-border cooperation,
and legal harmonization offer potential solutions,
continuous efforts are required to balance effective
copyright enforcement with digital rights and privacy
concerns .
The rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI),
blockchain, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) has
introduced new copyright complexities. Traditional
copyright laws struggle to address AI-generated works,
ownership of digital assets, and decentralized content-
sharing platforms. Without legal clarity, these
technologies pose challenges to existing copyright
enforcement strategies . The rapid advancement of
emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence
(AI), blockchain, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs), has
introduced complex copyright challenges that
traditional legal frameworks struggle to address. These
technologies
disrupt
conventional
notions
of
ownership, authorship, and content distribution,
exposing significant gaps in copyright regulation.
Without legal reforms, emerging technologies will
continue to outpace copyright enforcement, leading to
increased digital copyright disputes and enforcement
inefficiencies .
Despite international efforts, digital piracy remains a
major issue. File-sharing websites, illegal streaming
services, and darknet marketplaces continue to
facilitate unauthorized distribution of copyrighted
material. Weak enforcement mechanisms in certain
jurisdictions allow piracy networks to thrive,
undermining the global creative economy . Digital
piracy is a widespread issue that affects the global
creative economy, undermining legal content
distribution and intellectual property protection. The
rapid growth of digital platforms and evolving methods
of unauthorized content distribution have fueled an
expansive black market for copyrighted materials.
Addressing digital piracy requires a multi-faceted
approach, combining legal, technological, and
educational strategies to protect intellectual property
rights while fostering a sustainable digital economy.
The anonymity of the internet, coupled with the use of
virtual private networks (VPNs) and proxy servers,
makes it difficult to track and prosecute copyright
violators. Many infringers operate in jurisdictions with
lax copyright enforcement, complicating cross-border
legal actions . The enforcement of copyright laws in
virtual space is significantly hampered by the difficulty
of identifying and tracking infringers. As digital piracy
and unauthorized content distribution continue to
evolve, infringers use various techniques to remain
anonymous and evade legal consequences . This
challenge stems from technological, legal, and
jurisdictional factors that complicate efforts to hold
violators accountable. There are a lot of online
anonymity and evasion tactics. Firstly, many infringers
use Virtual Private Networks (VPNs), proxy servers, and
Tor networks to mask their real IP addresses, making it
difficult for copyright enforcers to trace them.
Secondly, some websites and online platforms operate
on decentralized networks, preventing authorities
from shutting them down easily . Thirdly, the use of
temporary or disposable domain names allows
infringers to frequently change their website addresses
and continue operating under different identities.
Despite these difficulties, continued advancements in
digital enforcement mechanisms and stronger legal
frameworks will be essential to improving the tracking
and prosecution of copyright infringers in virtual space
.
Fair use and copyright exceptions are essential
components of copyright law, allowing limited use of
copyrighted material without permission from the
copyright holder. These exceptions help balance the
rights of creators with the public’s interest in accessing
and using copyrighted works for education,
commentary, research, and other socially beneficial
purposes . However, fair use is not universally defined
and varies significantly across different legal systems.
The concept of fair use varies significantly across legal
systems, creating ambiguity in digital content usage.
While some countries have broad fair use provisions
that allow limited reproduction of copyrighted material
for education, commentary, and research, others
impose strict limitations . This inconsistency leads to
International Journal of Law And Criminology
37
https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc
International Journal of Law And Criminology (ISSN: 2771-2214)
legal uncertainties for digital content creators and
users.
A more unified approach to copyright protection
requires stronger international collaboration. Efforts to
harmonize copyright laws across jurisdictions can
improve enforcement and provide greater legal
certainty. Organizations such as the World Intellectual
Property Organization (WIPO) and the World Trade
Organization (WTO) play a crucial role in facilitating
such
cooperation.
Strengthening
international
cooperation is essential for addressing the challenges
of copyright enforcement in virtual space. Since digital
content transcends national borders, a fragmented
approach to copyright protection creates enforcement
gaps that infringers can exploit. One of the major
obstacles to effective copyright enforcement is the lack
of harmonization across jurisdictions. Countries
interpret and implement international treaties
differently, leading to inconsistencies in copyright
duration, fair use provisions, and enforcement
mechanisms . Efforts to establish a more unified legal
framework through global organizations like the World
Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the
World Trade Organization (WTO) can help create a
more predictable and efficient copyright system. Cross-
Border Enforcement Mechanisms Piracy networks
often operate across multiple jurisdictions, making it
difficult to take legal action against infringers.
Strengthening
cross-border
enforcement
mechanisms
—
such as international copyright dispute
resolution frameworks and bilateral cooperation
agreements
—
can help streamline legal processes for
prosecuting copyright violations in digital space. Joint
Technological Initiatives International cooperation in
technology-driven copyright enforcement can enhance
protection measures. Governments and copyright
organizations can collaborate on global digital
fingerprinting
databases,
automated
content
recognition systems, and blockchain-based copyright
registries to improve tracking and verification of
copyrighted material across platforms . Developing
countries often lack the resources and expertise to
enforce copyright laws effectively. International
cooperation can facilitate training programs, technical
assistance, and knowledge-sharing initiatives to
enhance the capacity of national agencies responsible
for copyright protection . Encouraging global
collaboration among policymakers, legal experts, and
technology developers can further strengthen
copyright enforcement efforts. By fostering stronger
international cooperation, the global community can
create a more cohesive and efficient copyright
protection framework, ensuring that digital content
remains safeguarded against infringement in the
evolving virtual landscape.
Blockchain technology offers a decentralized and
transparent way to track digital content ownership and
copyright claims. Smart contracts can automate
licensing agreements and royalty payments, reducing
disputes over digital content usage. If widely adopted,
blockchain could revolutionize copyright protection in
virtual space. Blockchain technology presents a
promising solution for copyright protection in virtual
space. Its decentralized, transparent, and immutable
nature can help address challenges related to copyright
enforcement, digital piracy, and intellectual property
rights management. Blockchain enables creators to
register their works on a tamper-proof ledger,
providing irrefutable proof of ownership. By storing
metadata, timestamps, and digital signatures,
blockchain can establish a secure record of authorship
that is accessible worldwide. This can help resolve
copyright disputes and strengthen claims in cases of
infringement.
Smart
contracts
—
self-executing
agreements coded into the blockchain
—
can automate
licensing and royalty payments for digital content.
When a user accesses or purchases copyrighted
material, the smart contract ensures that the content
owner receives automatic compensation. This
eliminates intermediaries, reduces transaction costs,
and ensures fair compensation for creators.
Blockchain’s transparent ledger allows for real
-time
tracking of digital assets, making it easier to detect
unauthorized distribution. By embedding unique digital
fingerprints (hashes) within content, creators can
monitor the spread of their works across platforms and
take action against piracy more efficiently. Traditional
copyright enforcement relies on national laws and
centralized authorities, which can be inconsistent and
ineffective across jurisdictions. Blockchain offers a
decentralized approach, where a global, publicly
verifiable record of copyright ownership and
transactions exists . This reduces reliance on
government institutions and enables a more uniform
international copyright enforcement system. While
blockchain provides significant advantages, its
widespread adoption faces challenges, including legal
recognition, scalability issues, and high energy
consumption in some blockchain models. Moreover,
integrating blockchain with existing copyright
frameworks requires international cooperation and
technological
standardization
.
By
leveraging
blockchain for copyright protection, the digital
economy can benefit from greater transparency,
security, and efficiency, ensuring that creators receive
proper recognition and compensation in the evolving
virtual landscape.
AI-powered content recognition tools, such as
International Journal of Law And Criminology
38
https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc
International Journal of Law And Criminology (ISSN: 2771-2214)
YouTube’s Content ID system, have shown promise in
detecting unauthorized content usage. Expanding AI-
driven copyright enforcement across digital platforms
can enhance protection while reducing reliance on
traditional litigation. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is playing
an increasingly vital role in copyright enforcement,
offering innovative solutions to detect and prevent
intellectual property violations in the digital space. As
online content distribution grows exponentially, AI-
driven systems provide an efficient, scalable, and
automated approach to copyright protection. AI-based
tools can automatically scan and analyze vast amounts
of digital content across websites, social media, and
streaming platforms. Systems like YouTube’s Content
ID and Facebook’s Rights Manager use machine
learning to detect copyrighted material by comparing
uploaded content against a database of registered
works. These systems help rightsholders identify
unauthorized use and take action, such as
monetization, removal, or blocking. AI-driven copyright
enforcement is transforming digital rights management
by enabling faster, more efficient detection and
prevention of infringement. However, balancing
enforcement with fair use rights, improving AI
accuracy, and addressing ethical concerns remain
critical to ensuring an effective and equitable copyright
protection system in virtual space .
To address legal ambiguities surrounding AI-generated
content, NFTs, and decentralized content-sharing
platforms, copyright laws must evolve. Clear guidelines
on ownership, licensing, and attribution in virtual space
are essential to protect creators while fostering
innovation. The rapid evolution of digital and emerging
technologies
—
such as artificial intelligence (AI),
blockchain, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs)
—
has
outpaced existing copyright laws, creating legal
ambiguities and enforcement challenges. To ensure
effective copyright protection while fostering
innovation, legal frameworks must adapt to address
these new technological realities. AI is increasingly
being used to create original works, raising questions
about authorship and copyright ownership. Current
copyright laws often assume human authorship,
leaving uncertainty about whether AI-generated works
can be copyrighted and who should hold the rights
—
the AI developer, the user, or the AI itself. Legal reforms
should:
•
Establish clear rules on AI-assisted versus AI-
generated content.
•
Define copyright ownership for AI-generated
works.
•
Ensure fair attribution and licensing models for
AI-driven creative processes.
Reforming copyright laws for emerging technologies is
essential to maintaining a balanced intellectual
property system that protects creators while
promoting innovation. By addressing AI-generated
works, blockchain-based content, decentralized
networks, and modern fair use principles, policymakers
can create a more flexible and effective legal
framework for the digital age.
The challenges of international copyright regulation in
virtual space stem from legal gaps, jurisdictional
conflicts, and enforcement difficulties. While current
frameworks provide a foundation for protection,
inconsistencies across jurisdictions hinder effective
enforcement. Future advancements in copyright
governance
should
focus
on
international
harmonization, technological solutions like blockchain
and AI, and legal adaptations for emerging digital
trends. Strengthening global cooperation and
embracing innovative enforcement mechanisms will be
key to ensuring effective copyright protection in the
digital. The regulation of international copyright in
virtual space remains fraught with legal gaps and
enforcement challenges. Disparities in national
implementation,
jurisdictional
conflicts,
and
inadequate frameworks for emerging technologies
hinder effective protection of digital content. The rise
of digital piracy and difficulties in tracking infringers
further complicate enforcement efforts. However,
promising solutions lie in strengthening international
cooperation, leveraging blockchain for copyright
authentication, employing artificial intelligence for
content monitoring, and adapting copyright laws to
technological advancements. A unified and forward-
thinking approach is essential to create a balanced
copyright system that safeguards creators’ rights while
fostering innovation and accessibility in the digital era.
REFERENCES
Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and
Artistic Works, 1886.
WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT), 1996.
Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual
Property Rights (TRIPS), 1994.
Universal Copyright Convention (UCC), 1952.
Marrakesh Treaty to Facilitate Access to Published
Works for Persons Who Are Blind, 2013.
Ginsburg, J. C. (2018). "International Copyright: From a
'Bundle' of National Copyright Laws to a Supranational
Code?" Columbia Law Review.
Hugenholtz, P. B. (2020). "Fair Use in International
Copyright Law: A Comparative Analysis." Journal of
Intellectual Property Law.
Samuelson, P. (2019). "The Challenges of Enforcing
International Journal of Law And Criminology
39
https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc
International Journal of Law And Criminology (ISSN: 2771-2214)
Copyright in the Digital Era." Harvard Journal of Law &
Technology.
Okediji, R. (2017). "The Global Intellectual Property
System and Digital Rights." Yale Law Journal.
Geiger, C. (2021). "Copyright in the Age of Artificial
Intelligence: Legal and Ethical Perspectives." European
Intellectual Property Review.
WIPO. (2021). "Challenges in Copyright Enforcement in
the Digital Environment." World Intellectual Property
Organization Report.
European Commission. (2020). "Digital Single Market
and Copyright Reform."
U.S. Copyright Office. (2019). "Artificial Intelligence and
Copyright: A Policy Report."
UNESCO. (2022). "Balancing Copyright Protection and
Access to Knowledge in Digital Spaces."
WTO. (2021). "Intellectual Property and Trade in the
Digital Age.
IFPI. (2020). "Global Music Piracy Report: Trends and
Countermeasures."
Motion Picture Association. (2019). "The Economic
Impact of Digital Piracy on the Film Industry."
OECD. (2021). "The Global Black Market for Digital
Content and Its Impact on Creativity."
USTR. (2022). "Notorious Markets for Counterfeiting
and Piracy."
Business Software Alliance (BSA)
