EDUCATION MANAGEMENT IN PRIVATE UNIVERSITIES IN UZBEKISTAN: DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES, CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS

Abstract

The article examines the peculiarities of the management of private higher education institutions in Uzbekistan, their role in the country's educational system, and the key challenges and prospects for development. The author analyses the unique aspects of private HEIs management, such as autonomy, financial independence, and orientation to the needs of students. Special attention is paid to the challenges faced by private HEIs, including competition, public trust, financial sustainability, and government regulation. The article also presents statistical data on Uzbekistan and foreign experience, provides a comparative analysis, and suggests promising directions for development, such as digitalisation of education, partnership with business and international expansion. The article concludes with a conclusion on the importance of strategic management and adaptation of private HEIs to modern challenges.

 

 

Source type: Journals
Years of coverage from 2023
inLibrary
Google Scholar
Branch of knowledge
CC BY f
308-313
316

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
To share
Shadiyev , . A. (2025). EDUCATION MANAGEMENT IN PRIVATE UNIVERSITIES IN UZBEKISTAN: DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES, CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence, 1(2), 308–313. Retrieved from https://www.inlibrary.uz/index.php/ijai/article/view/73565
Crossref
Сrossref
Scopus
Scopus

Abstract

The article examines the peculiarities of the management of private higher education institutions in Uzbekistan, their role in the country's educational system, and the key challenges and prospects for development. The author analyses the unique aspects of private HEIs management, such as autonomy, financial independence, and orientation to the needs of students. Special attention is paid to the challenges faced by private HEIs, including competition, public trust, financial sustainability, and government regulation. The article also presents statistical data on Uzbekistan and foreign experience, provides a comparative analysis, and suggests promising directions for development, such as digitalisation of education, partnership with business and international expansion. The article concludes with a conclusion on the importance of strategic management and adaptation of private HEIs to modern challenges.

 

 


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 308

EDUCATION MANAGEMENT IN PRIVATE UNIVERSITIES IN UZBEKISTAN:

DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES, CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS

Shadiyev A.X.

Asia international university, Bukhara

Annotation:

The article examines the peculiarities of the management of private higher

education institutions in Uzbekistan, their role in the country's educational system, and the key

challenges and prospects for development. The author analyses the unique aspects of private

HEIs management, such as autonomy, financial independence, and orientation to the needs of

students. Special attention is paid to the challenges faced by private HEIs, including competition,

public trust, financial sustainability, and government regulation. The article also presents

statistical data on Uzbekistan and foreign experience, provides a comparative analysis, and

suggests promising directions for development, such as digitalisation of education, partnership

with business and international expansion. The article concludes with a conclusion on the

importance of strategic management and adaptation of private HEIs to modern challenges.

Key words:

private universities, education management, Uzbekistan, autonomy, financial

independence, quality of education, digitalisation, international cooperation, employment of

graduates, state regulation.

Private universities in Uzbekistan have become an integral part of the country's educational

system, offering an alternative to public institutions. Their role in training qualified personnel,

introducing innovative teaching methods and meeting the needs of the labour market is

becoming increasingly important. However, the management of private HEIs in Uzbekistan

presents a number of unique challenges that require a strategic approach and adaptation to local

conditions. This article will examine the specifics of private HEIs management in Uzbekistan,

their problems and development prospects, and provide specific examples from the practice of

private HEIs in Uzbekistan and other countries.

A study of the peculiarities of the management of private universities in Uzbekistan reveals

three key distinctions from public institutions. Firstly, their organisational structure differs

significantly. Secondly, they operate based on distinct funding principles. Thirdly, they enjoy a

greater level of autonomy in decision-making. These unique features combine to create a

distinctive environment for managing the educational process, enabling private HEIs to adapt

more flexibly to market demands and innovate in their approaches to teaching and administration.

Private universities in Uzbekistan benefit from greater autonomy and flexibility, allowing

them to develop innovative curricula and implement advanced teaching methods. For instance,

INHA University in Tashkent has been at the forefront of adopting cutting-edge educational

technologies, such as online courses and blended learning. This ability to swiftly adapt to

evolving market trends enables the university to offer contemporary and relevant educational

programmes, ensuring that students gain modern and competitive skills..

Financial independence is a crucial issue for universities in Uzbekistan. In contrast to state-

run institutions, private universities in Uzbekistan are reliant on tuition fees and investments to

generate revenue. A case in point is AMITY University, which has forged collaborative

relationships with both local and international companies, offering bespoke corporate training

programmes and consultancy services. This strategic approach enables the university to diversify

its revenue streams and mitigate financial risks.


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 309

Private universities in Uzbekistan face considerable competition for applicants, which

necessitates a strong focus on the quality of educational services and infrastructure development.

For instance, Webster University in Tashkent has established contemporary co-working spaces

and career centres that assist students in securing employment even before graduation, thereby

enhancing the institution's appeal and meeting the evolving needs of students.

The management of private universities in Uzbekistan is a complex process that involves

addressing several critical challenges. Among the most significant is ensuring the quality of

education, which is of paramount importance. It is incumbent upon the management of private

HEIs to ensure that curricula meet modern standards and that teaching staff are highly qualified.

For example, INHA University in Tashkent engages practitioners from various industries in

curriculum development to ensure the relevance and applicability of the material taught, thereby

aligning educational outcomes with market demands.

Attracting applicants in a highly competitive environment. In the context of intense

competition among private higher education institutions in Uzbekistan, active marketing and

promotion of services has become essential. A case in point is AMITY University, which holds

open days, participates in educational fairs and maintains a strong presence on social media.

Moreover, the university offers scholarships and discounts to talented students, thereby

enhancing its attractiveness.

Infrastructure development in higher education: the modern university is under pressure to

provide students with quality education and comfortable learning conditions. For example,

Webster University in Tashkent is investing in the creation of modern classrooms, laboratories

and libraries with access to electronic resources.

International cooperation is of paramount importance in the contemporary higher education

landscape. The participation of universities in international programmes, such as the Erasmus+

programme, along with the acquisition of international accreditation, serves to enhance the

prestige of the institution and attract a global student population. A notable example of this

commitment to internationalisation is INHA University in Tashkent, which has significantly

expanded its offerings to include dual degree programmes that allow students to pursue studies

in both Uzbekistan and abroad.

Despite their numerous advantages, private higher educational institutions in Uzbekistan

are facing a number of significant challenges that could potentially affect their development and

stability. These challenges include problems related to public confidence, regulatory compliance,

financial limitations, and competition from public universities. All of these require strategic

solutions in order to ensure long-term growth and success.

In the context of the education market, there is a high level of competition between private

and state universities. A case in point is the lower tuition fees and employment guarantees

offered by state HEIs, such as the National University of Uzbekistan, which serve to enhance

their appeal to prospective students.

1

.

Public trust in private universities remains a challenge. A considerable number of

individuals still believe that the quality of education in private institutions is inferior to that of

public universities. To address this perception, private universities, such as AMITY University,

actively disseminate employment ratings of their graduates and share testimonials from

1

Abdullaev, R. (2020).

Higher Education Reforms in Uzbekistan: Challenges and Opportunities

. Tashkent: Uzbekistan Education

Press.


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 310

successful students to substantiate their credibility and demonstrate the value of their educational

programmes.

The financial sustainability of private universities is contingent on tuition fees, which

renders them vulnerable during periods of economic crises or reduced demand for education. For

instance, INHA University in Tashkent has established an endowment fund with the objective of

accumulating resources for long-term development..

State regulation requires private higher education institutions in Uzbekistan to adhere to

prevailing legal requirements, which include licensing, accreditation, and the submission of

reports. For instance, private HEIs undergo regular inspections by regulatory authorities, a

process that is both time-consuming and costly, ensuring compliance with established standards

and maintaining the quality of education

2

.

Statistical data on Uzbekistan The following data on the number of universities in

Uzbekistan has been collated from the Ministry of Higher and Secondary Specialised Education

of Uzbekistan:

Development of private universities in Uzbekistan

Indicator

Meaning

Number of private universities in 2023

50+ (≈30% of the total number of universities)

Growth in the number of private universities

in 5 years

+20%

For students of private universities

≈15% (≈150 000 students)

Forecast for 2025

20% of the total number of students

Employment of graduates

75% in the first year after graduation

Popular destinations

IT,

business

administration,

engineering

specialties

Tuition fee (per year)

$2 000 – $5 000

Endowment funds (examples)

Inha University – $10-20 million

Comparison with other countries

Country

The share of private

universities

Average tuition fee

(per year)

The

level

of

employment

of

graduates

Uzbekistan

30%

$2 000 – $5 000

75%

USA

40%

$20 000 – $50 000

80–90%

Great Britain

10%

£12 000 – £20 000

95%

India

20%

$2 000 – $10 000

Not specified

Despite the challenges currently being faced, the outlook for the development of private

higher education institutions Uzbekistan remains positive and significant. The following key

areas are identified as those in which growth and development are to be focused:

The digitalisation of education, encompassing the implementation of online courses, the

utilisation of distance learning platforms, and the development of digital educational resources,

2

Abdullaev, R. (2020).

Higher Education Reforms in Uzbekistan: Challenges and Opportunities

. Tashkent: Uzbekistan Education

Press.


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 311

enables private universities to attract students from diverse geographical locations and

nationalities. A notable illustration of this phenomenon is INHA University in Tashkent, which

offers fully online programmes that facilitate students in balancing academic pursuits with

professional commitments.

A partnership between a university and a business entity facilitates the development of

relevant curricula that align with the demands of the labour market. For instance, AMITY

University has established collaborative relationships with prominent corporations, leading to the

establishment of joint laboratories where students can engage in authentic project work, thereby

acquiring practical experience and competencies that are in high demand within the professional

sphere.

The individualisation of learning, underpinned by the utilisation of big data and artificial

intelligence technologies, facilitates the creation of personalised educational trajectories that are

tailored to the interests and abilities of each student. For instance, Webster University in

Tashkent employs adaptive learning systems that automatically adapt learning material to the

level of knowledge and needs of students, thereby ensuring a more effective and flexible

educational process.

3

.

International expansion, including obtaining international accreditation and participating in

global educational initiatives, contributes to the increasing prestige of the university. For

example, INHA University in Tashkent actively develops international cooperation by opening

branches abroad, entering into partnerships with foreign universities and expanding its influence

and student opportunities.

Examples from the practice of private universities in different countries demonstrate the

diversity of approaches to the organisation of the educational process (Smith, 2019). In the USA,

the University of Phoenix, one of the largest private universities, specialises in online education,

offering flexible programmes that allow students to combine study and work (Brown et al.,

2021). In the UK, the University of Buckingham, the country's first private university, attracts

students with accelerated programmes that allow them to complete a bachelor's degree in just

two years, a particularly appealing option for those seeking to enter the job market faster. In

India, Amity University, one of the largest private higher education institutions, actively

introduces innovative technologies, offers dual degree programmes with foreign universities and

cooperates with international companies thereby strengthening its position in the global

education arena.

The state plays a pivotal role in the regulation of private universities by establishing a

legislative framework that determines their functioning, the quality of education they provide,

and their competitiveness in the educational sector. In Uzbekistan, private HEIs are subject to

regulatory mechanisms such as licensing, accreditation, and quality control, which ensure

compliance with educational standards and contribute to the enhancement of the services they

provide.

It is imperative for private higher education institutions to undertake licensing and

accreditation procedures in order to verify that their educational programmes are in alignment

with the stipulated state standards.

The state is responsible for the quality control of education, and this is achieved through

regular inspections, audits, monitoring of curricula and assessment of teachers qualifications.

3

https://www.itsmypost.com/educational-initiatives-of-shavkat-mirziyoyev-transforming-uzbekistans-future/


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 312

State support for private universities may be provided through tax incentives and the

creation of endowment funds for their long-term financing.

Conclusion

Education management in private higher educational institutions in Uzbekistan is a

complex and multi-faceted process that requires not only deep knowledge of the field of

education but also skills in strategic planning, marketing, and financial management. Despite the

difficulties, private universities play a significant role in training skilled professionals,

introducing innovations, and meeting the demands of modern society. Their success depends

largely on their ability to adjust to change, provide high-quality educational services, and

effectively utilize existing resources. In the future, it is likely that private universities will

continue to grow, utilizing new technologies and enhancing their position in the international

education market.

References:

1.

Qudratova, G. M. (2025). THE EVALUATION OF UNIVERSITY COMPETITIVENESS:

A REVIEW OF METHODOLOGIES. SHOKH LIBRARY.

2.

Azimov, B. F., Maksudovich, A. Z., & Qudratova, G. M. (2025). THE IMPORTANCE OF

INNOVATION IN ENHANCING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF HIGHER EDUCATION

UNIVERSITIES. SHOKH LIBRARY.

3.

Husenov, A., & Qudratova, G. (2025). RAQOBAT VA RAQOBAT STRATEGIYALARI:

NAZARIY VA AMALIY YONDASHUVLAR. Modern Science and Research, 4(2), 292-

299.

4.

Sodiqova, N. (2025). METHODOLOGY FOR DEVELOPING STUDENTS'TECHNICAL

THINKING IN ECONOMICS CLASSES. International Journal of Artificial

Intelligence, 1(1), 885-891.

5.

Islomova, M., & Sodiqova, N. (2025). ILM-FAN VA TA'LIMDAGI INNOVATION

RIVOJLANISHNING DOLZARB MUAMMOLARI. Modern Science and Research, 4(2),

300-307.

6.

Bahodirovich, X. B., & To’rayevna, S. N. (2025). LOMBARD TASHKILOTLARI VA

ULARNING XIZMATLARI. THEORY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE

WORLDT, 1(3), 290-298.

7.

Bahodirovich, X. B. (2025). XO’JALIK YURITUVCHI SUBYEKTLARDA HISOB

YURITISH SIYOSATI. STUDYING THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE AND ITS

SHORTCOMINGS, 1(6), 210-215.

8.

Bahodirovich, X. B. (2025). BUXGALTERIYA HISOBINING O’RGANISH

USULLARI. THEORY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE WORLDT, 1(5),

257-262.

9.

Bakhodirovich, K. B. (2023). CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATIONS OF IMPROVING

ACCOUNTING IN SMALL BUSINESS AND PRIVATE ENTREPRENEURSHIP. IMRAS,

6 (6), 161–165.

10.

Ёкубов, А. Б., & Алимова, Ш. А. (2024). МАКРОЭКОНОМИКА: ЭВОЛЮЦИЯ

ТЕОРИИ И СОВРЕМЕННОЙ ПРАКТИКИ.

11.

Abidovna, A. S. (2025). INVESTMENT PROJECTS: ADVANCED MANAGEMENT AND

EVALUATION. SHOKH LIBRARY.


background image

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE

ISSN: 2692-5206, Impact Factor: 12,23

American Academic publishers, volume 05, issue 03,2025

Journal:

https://www.academicpublishers.org/journals/index.php/ijai

page 313

12.

Бахтиёров, Д., & Алимова, Ш. А. (2025). КОНКУРЕНЦИЯ НА РЫНКЕ: КАК БОРЬБА

КОМПАНИЙ ВЛИЯЕТ НА ЦЕНЫ, КАЧЕСТВО И ИННОВАЦИИ. Modern Science and

Research, 4(2), 463-471.

13.

Hakimovich, T. M. (2025). EKSPORT RAQOBATBARDOSHLIGINI OSHIRISHDA

DIVERSIFIKATSIYANING AHAMIYATI. STUDYING THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE

AND ITS SHORTCOMINGS, 1(4), 112-121.

14.

Hakimovich, T. M. (2025). O ‘ZBEKISTONDA EKSPORTNI RAG ‘BATLANTIRISH

UCHUN FOYDALANILADIGAN MOLIYAVIY VOSITALAR TAHLILI. MODERN

EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM AND INNOVATIVE TEACHING SOLUTIONS, 1(5), 141-150.

15.

Bobojonova, M. J., & Toshev, M. H. (2025). YASHIL IQTISODIYOTI RIVOJLANISH

TARIXI VA SHAKLLANISHI. ANALYSIS OF MODERN SCIENCE AND

INNOVATION, 1(5), 154-159.

16.

Ibodulloyevich, I. E. (2024). O ‘ZBEKISTON RESPUBLIKASIDA KICHIK BIZNES VA

XUSUSIY TADBIRKORLIK SAMARADORLIGINI OSHIRISH MUAMMOLARI VA

ISHBILARMONLIK MUHITINI YAXSHILASH ISTIQBOLLARI. Gospodarka i

Innowacje., 51, 258-266.

17.

EI, I. (2025). MINTAQALAR VA MA’MURIY HUDUDLAR TADBIRKORLIK

FAOLIYATINI INVESTITSIYA BILAN TA’MINLOVCHI IQTISODIY TIZIM

SIFATIDA. MODERN EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM AND INNOVATIVE TEACHING

SOLUTIONS, 1(6), 58-69.

18.

EI, I. (2025). MINTAQALARDA TADBIRKORLIK FAOLIYATINI RIVOJLANTIRISH

VA

UNI

INVESTITSIYA

BILAN

TA’MINLASHNING

O

‘ZIGA

XOS

XUSUSIYATLARI. MODERN PROBLEMS IN EDUCATION AND THEIR SCIENTIFIC

SOLUTIONS, 1(5), 39-50.

19.

Azimov, B. F., & Yodgorova, Z. Y. (2025). METHODS OF STUDYING THE STATE OF

COMPETITION IN THE EDUCATIONAL SERVICES MARKET. SHOKH LIBRARY.

20.

Azimov, B. F. (2025). INNOVATSIYALARNI QO ‘LLAB-QUVVATLASH

XIZMATLARI: ISPANIYA, POLSHA VA BOLGARIYA TAJRIBALARI. THEORY OF

SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE WORLDT, 1(4), 12-23.

References

Qudratova, G. M. (2025). THE EVALUATION OF UNIVERSITY COMPETITIVENESS: A REVIEW OF METHODOLOGIES. SHOKH LIBRARY.

Azimov, B. F., Maksudovich, A. Z., & Qudratova, G. M. (2025). THE IMPORTANCE OF INNOVATION IN ENHANCING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF HIGHER EDUCATION UNIVERSITIES. SHOKH LIBRARY.

Husenov, A., & Qudratova, G. (2025). RAQOBAT VA RAQOBAT STRATEGIYALARI: NAZARIY VA AMALIY YONDASHUVLAR. Modern Science and Research, 4(2), 292-299.

Sodiqova, N. (2025). METHODOLOGY FOR DEVELOPING STUDENTS'TECHNICAL THINKING IN ECONOMICS CLASSES. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence, 1(1), 885-891.

Islomova, M., & Sodiqova, N. (2025). ILM-FAN VA TA'LIMDAGI INNOVATION RIVOJLANISHNING DOLZARB MUAMMOLARI. Modern Science and Research, 4(2), 300-307.

Bahodirovich, X. B., & To’rayevna, S. N. (2025). LOMBARD TASHKILOTLARI VA ULARNING XIZMATLARI. THEORY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE WORLDT, 1(3), 290-298.

Bahodirovich, X. B. (2025). XO’JALIK YURITUVCHI SUBYEKTLARDA HISOB YURITISH SIYOSATI. STUDYING THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE AND ITS SHORTCOMINGS, 1(6), 210-215.

Bahodirovich, X. B. (2025). BUXGALTERIYA HISOBINING O’RGANISH USULLARI. THEORY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE WORLDT, 1(5), 257-262.

Bakhodirovich, K. B. (2023). CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATIONS OF IMPROVING ACCOUNTING IN SMALL BUSINESS AND PRIVATE ENTREPRENEURSHIP. IMRAS, 6 (6), 161–165.

Ёкубов, А. Б., & Алимова, Ш. А. (2024). МАКРОЭКОНОМИКА: ЭВОЛЮЦИЯ ТЕОРИИ И СОВРЕМЕННОЙ ПРАКТИКИ.

Abidovna, A. S. (2025). INVESTMENT PROJECTS: ADVANCED MANAGEMENT AND EVALUATION. SHOKH LIBRARY.

Бахтиёров, Д., & Алимова, Ш. А. (2025). КОНКУРЕНЦИЯ НА РЫНКЕ: КАК БОРЬБА КОМПАНИЙ ВЛИЯЕТ НА ЦЕНЫ, КАЧЕСТВО И ИННОВАЦИИ. Modern Science and Research, 4(2), 463-471.

Hakimovich, T. M. (2025). EKSPORT RAQOBATBARDOSHLIGINI OSHIRISHDA DIVERSIFIKATSIYANING AHAMIYATI. STUDYING THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE AND ITS SHORTCOMINGS, 1(4), 112-121.

Hakimovich, T. M. (2025). O ‘ZBEKISTONDA EKSPORTNI RAG ‘BATLANTIRISH UCHUN FOYDALANILADIGAN MOLIYAVIY VOSITALAR TAHLILI. MODERN EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM AND INNOVATIVE TEACHING SOLUTIONS, 1(5), 141-150.

Bobojonova, M. J., & Toshev, M. H. (2025). YASHIL IQTISODIYOTI RIVOJLANISH TARIXI VA SHAKLLANISHI. ANALYSIS OF MODERN SCIENCE AND INNOVATION, 1(5), 154-159.

Ibodulloyevich, I. E. (2024). O ‘ZBEKISTON RESPUBLIKASIDA KICHIK BIZNES VA XUSUSIY TADBIRKORLIK SAMARADORLIGINI OSHIRISH MUAMMOLARI VA ISHBILARMONLIK MUHITINI YAXSHILASH ISTIQBOLLARI. Gospodarka i Innowacje., 51, 258-266.

EI, I. (2025). MINTAQALAR VA MA’MURIY HUDUDLAR TADBIRKORLIK FAOLIYATINI INVESTITSIYA BILAN TA’MINLOVCHI IQTISODIY TIZIM SIFATIDA. MODERN EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM AND INNOVATIVE TEACHING SOLUTIONS, 1(6), 58-69.

EI, I. (2025). MINTAQALARDA TADBIRKORLIK FAOLIYATINI RIVOJLANTIRISH VA UNI INVESTITSIYA BILAN TA’MINLASHNING O ‘ZIGA XOS XUSUSIYATLARI. MODERN PROBLEMS IN EDUCATION AND THEIR SCIENTIFIC SOLUTIONS, 1(5), 39-50.

Azimov, B. F., & Yodgorova, Z. Y. (2025). METHODS OF STUDYING THE STATE OF COMPETITION IN THE EDUCATIONAL SERVICES MARKET. SHOKH LIBRARY.

Azimov, B. F. (2025). INNOVATSIYALARNI QO ‘LLAB-QUVVATLASH XIZMATLARI: ISPANIYA, POLSHA VA BOLGARIYA TAJRIBALARI. THEORY OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES OF WHOLE WORLDT, 1(4), 12-23.